-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Glad to hear I met expectations!
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Thanks Coralie! It’s set in the same universe as a number of other stories I’ve published on my website (https://josiahdegraaf.com/), so that’s probably why it feels like part of a larger world. 😉
What sentence seemed to be missing a word? I’ll want to go back and fix it if that’s the case. 😛
-
Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic *waves* Heyo! in the forum Introduce Yourself 8 years, 6 months ago
Hey @devestate-lasting! Welcome to the Story Embers forum. 🙂 What’s the premise of your current work-in-progress? And do you have specific questions about what’s going on here that I can answer for you?
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Haha; thanks Cheyenne.
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Yeah; that’s fair. 😛
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Thanks Devestate!
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Yeah; I’m unfortunately not terribly kind to my characters.
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Thanks Joy!
-
Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic File has arrived! in the forum Introduce Yourself 8 years, 6 months ago
Thanks @filewriter! I published two short stories on KP–“Hero of the Empire” about a space pilot who needs to decide whether or not to turn in his girlfriend for desertion, and “To Whom the Future Belongs” about a woman who needs to decide if she should change the future to save her son. Glad you enjoyed whichever story it was, though. xD I…[Read more]
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Probably wise.
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Sorry. 😛
-
Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic File has arrived! in the forum Introduce Yourself 8 years, 6 months ago
Welcome to the site @filewriter! Cool profile pic. 🙂
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Thanks! I’m looking forward to writing more about Emiel in the future. 🙂
-
Josiah DeGraaf changed their profile picture 8 years, 6 months ago
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Compared to one of the greats! I’m honored. xD Glad you enjoyed it!
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Thanks Daeus!
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 8 years, 6 months ago
Yeah; I had fun doing some false foreshadowing in this story. 😉 Glad you enjoyed it despite the pain of his choice.
-
Josiah DeGraaf wrote a new post 8 years, 6 months ago
A Heretic's Sacrifice
Emiel was twice a heretic. Â When he rejected the Twelve Gods for Adolsin, the church labeled him a heretic. And when he held onto the Twelve […]-
Can I just say…
Ouch.
That title is deceptive. This whole time I was preparing to be angry with you because you were going to kill this character that I was getting attached to. But then…
Ouch.
Man. Fantastic job with Emiel’s struggle and his ultimate choice.
-
Yeah; I had fun doing some false foreshadowing in this story. 😉 Glad you enjoyed it despite the pain of his choice.
-
-
I’m going to second Gabby.
/Ouch./
I think though that this is my favorite of your short stories thus far.
-
Thanks Daeus!
-
-
Wow, this has a real Sanderson feel to it. And owww, feels. </3
This is so good, though. I really liked it.
-
Compared to one of the greats! I’m honored. xD Glad you enjoyed it!
-
-
To quote previous commentators… OUCH.
Ow. That hurts. That really hurts. *gingerly cradles head and tries not to whimper*
-
Sorry. 😛
-
I don’t believe you. 😛
-
Probably wise.
-
-
OH WOW. This is really good. *nodnod* It makes me really interested to know what’s going to happen to him, and in what ways he’ll change! Awesome story Josiah.
-
Thanks! I’m looking forward to writing more about Emiel in the future. 🙂
-
-
*whimpers*
-
Yeah; I’m unfortunately not terribly kind to my characters.
-
Or your readers, I think it’s fair to add.
The fact that I see myself in Emiel didn’t help anything either.
*curls up in a corner and consoles herself with chocolate* -
Yeah; that’s fair. 😛
-
-
Thanks Joy!
-
Oh my.
I have no comment.
But you did a fantastic job, I must say.
-
Thanks Devestate!
-
-
Haha; thanks Cheyenne.
-
Hmm, well, that was interesting. This feels like a smaller piece of a larger world. It’s clear you’ve built your world and culture, and you have a strong grip on your characters. I found one boo-boo and one sentence seemed like it may have been missing a word (or I just read it wrong over and over?), but other than that, the story was well written. As I’m sure was your intention, I liked the spin you put on the sacrifice. Thank you for sharing!
-
Thanks Coralie! It’s set in the same universe as a number of other stories I’ve published on my website (https://josiahdegraaf.com/), so that’s probably why it feels like part of a larger world. 😉
What sentence seemed to be missing a word? I’ll want to go back and fix it if that’s the case. 😛
-
That sentence is fine as is. Dialogue doesn’t have to be 100% grammatically correct (particularly with characters like Emiel), because real people don’t talk that way.
-
^Like my editor said, that was actually a deliberate choice. Emiel doesn’t care much for proper grammar, a trait that stems from his more flippant personality. 🙂
Thanks! One of my goals with my writings is to go against standard narrative conventions and take the unexpected route in some way or another. Glad to hear you enjoyed it!
-
-
😀 I’ve been waiting for a return to this world, and it didn’t disappoint.
-
Glad to hear I met expectations!
-
-
I know I’m late, but can I just say wow?! I don’t remember reading many short stories that are this powerful, or make me think as much as this did. I often see stories in which it’s obvious to the reader what the MC should choose, and those stories don’t challenge, or make such a huge impact, as this does. The powerful questions you raised don’t have easy answers and weren’t downplayed at all, and Emiel’s path doesn’t suddenly become clear to him. In that way, this story reminded me a lot of Flannery O’Connor’s short stories. Very, very well done! I rather liked Emiel, even if he is a bit of a coward, and I’m looking forward to seeing more of him in the future! 🙂
-
Thanks so much, SleepwalkingMK. 🙂 O’Connor is a big inspiration for me as a storyteller, and I’m glad to hear that my writing reminds you of hers in some ways.
-
-
Um, Josiah?
You may have just crushed my heart…-
You’re welcome?
-
Eh, I’m used to it. Hope and Kate have crushed my heart plenty of times already. 😀
-
Ah good; your heart’s gotten used to being crushed then.
-
Though… it gets harder and harder to put it back together… I wonder what will be the story that breaks it for good. I’m gonna put the odds on either you or Kate…
-
Perhaps one day one of us will manage to write a story with a happy ending to help pull it back together.
-
*sighs* I suppose it’ll have to be me. Out of all the writer’s I’ve met, I seem to be the least cruel and torturing.
Though there was that one time when my brother asked me who I’d killed in a book recently and I absent-mindedly replied, “Nobody. Well, a whole village, but they don’t count.” O.O
-
-
Ow. That hurt 😛 I really thought he was going to give himself up…
On the bright side, I’ve just begun outlining a short story with a negative arc, and yours showed me how to write a good one 😉
-
Glad to hear you found it helpful from an educational perspective! xD Hope that story goes well. 🙂
-
-
Ha! Well, I’m only judging, not competing. 😉
-
I believe we’ll want to eventually do those but I have no idea when that would be!
@christieaton would know the most about this.
-
That was a great story! So moving. Please post some more stories!
-
Thanks! I have a collection of short stories set in this same world on my website if you’re interested (https://josiahdegraaf.com/), and we’ve also got some short stories by other authors in the Story Embers publication pipeline that should be popping up here in the next couple months. 🙂
-
-
Thanks Michaela! I really enjoyed writing this story and am glad you enjoyed it. 🙂 I have a collection of short stories set in this same world on my website if you’re interested (https://josiahdegraaf.com/). Emiel isn’t in any of them, but I want to start writing a novella over the summer that Emiel will feature prominently in!
-
This was written well! I like that I was in the story immediately.
-
Thanks Parker! Glad you enjoyed it. 🙂
-
-
Ha. That could have been a fun alternate way to do it. At least if Emiel was able to get Aren’s memories so he could pull off such a deception. I’m honored to get a mini-HISHE for this. ^_^ Thanks!
-
Thanks Sarah! Glad to hear it kept your attention. 🙂 And yes–I definitely do hope to write more of him. This summer, I’m planning on writing the first draft of a novella that would star him in a major role. No idea when it will be finished, but I’ve got my fingers crossed that I’ll be able to complete that in the next 1-2 years.
-
Thanks Shannon! Yeah, I wouldn’t be a terribly good writer if I didn’t follow my own advice. 😉 Glad to hear you enjoyed it!
-
Wow, Josiah. Heartbreaking and thought-provoking and challenging. It made me look inside myself and wonder if I would truly pursue selflessness in the face of hardship and adversity or if I would keep myself in safety and comfort. This definitely wasn’t what I was expecting (way to mislead your readers with that title…), but that made it so much better. Had he sacrificed himself for the merchant, it would’ve been encouraging but relatively forgettable; this ending lingers long after you read it and prompts some soul-searching. Great job.
-
Thanks Cassandra! Really glad to hear about how it impacted you. 🙂
-
-
Thanks Evelyn! I do have more planned for Emiel sometime in the future. 🙂
-
Thanks Talia! I’m glad you enjoyed it. 🙂 I am planning to write a novella about him (and a few other characters), which will take a while to write, but I do hope to continue his journey eventually!
-
Wait, how have I never commented on this??
I read this story several months back, and it’s stuck HARD with me ever since. Just tonight I decided I had to come back and reread, and it was just as good the second time.
So… wow. Just wow. This was really powerful. And I see a lot of myself in Emiel AND I DON’T LIKE IT!!!! (But, I wish I had turquoise eyes. That would be cool.)
I’m just rambling at this point so I’ll shut up. But anyway. This was really good. REALLY. good. It’s quite possibly the best short story I’ve ever read, which is saying a lot.-
That’s really encouraging to hear, Hannah. 🙂 Thanks for taking the time to mention this!
-
-
I know I’m late by a few years, but I just now read this and… well, wow. I’m amazed. One, I wish I could write like this. And two, what a jarring, convicting message. I’ll echo Cassandra, this story will stay with me far longer than if it had ended the way we all thought it would. Not than I liked the ending, oh no, it makes my heart heavy. But it leaves me mulling over not only Emiel’s choices, but also my own. And that’s what sets this apart in my mind as truly excellent. Thanks for writing this, I’m so glad I got to read.
-
Thanks, Libby. I appreciate the comment and am glad that it left you with good questions to think on.
-
-
-
Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic My character is blind. Is my story doomed? in the forum Characters 8 years, 6 months ago
@morreafirebird If the question is: “Is it a bad idea to have a blind protagonist as the viewpoint character?”, I would say definitely not. I really like that idea, to be honest. Now, I don’t envy your task in figuring out how to write that. 😛 But it seems like a great way to explore a different kind of POV, as well as a great opportunity to put…[Read more]
-
Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic Help! My Story is Misbehaving in the forum Themes 8 years, 6 months ago
@quinn-ofallon Audrey & the Invizible Man have some good recommendations on this front. My general advice on themes is to think about really difficult, open-ended questions about the topic. For your specific story, perhaps a good question would be: “How long should you stay loyal to someone?” or “How should you figure out who you can trust?”
Once…[Read more]
- Load More












