fb

Activity

  • Mischievous Thwapling replied to the topic Such a Thing As Biblical Magic? in the forum General Writing Discussions 5 years, 6 months ago

    @dakota

    Yeah! Thanks! And I really recommend The Wingfeather Saga if you ever want to read it. 🙂

    @kimlikesart

    No problem! I’m glad that my question helped answer your’s, lol.

    @lonathecat

    That’s a really cool way to think about it! What you’re saying is kinda like the quote I said up there: “To a kitten, a bumblebee flying would look like magic…” That’s what you’re getting at, right?
    And yes, the sorcery and witchcraft is definitely not to be toyed with.  It’s dark stuff.

    And cool! Isn’t that kinda like the #2 magic @r-m-archer mentioned up there? The Illians abilities?

    @josiah

    Wow, that is a very good point.  I hadn’t even thought of the Elijah example!  That’s a very big distinction, like @r-m-archer‘s.  You have brought up many great arguments that previously had not even crossed my mind.  To me, the difference between what the bible was talking about concerning magic and the more fantasy type magic is pretty significant.

    @r-m-archer

    Woah, now that you’ve explained it, I recognize what you’re talking about in books I’ve read.  In one series, I believe the author had the #2 magic, and I think she executed it very well.  When I thought of it, the word “magic” didn’t cross my mind as much as “the characters’ abilities,” which I believe is part of the picture you’re trying to paint with that, correct?

    I heartily agree.  There’s BIG distinctions between the “magics,” and I think that, yes, #3 should be avoided, unless the author is doing what you described.  Even then, I would be very cautious, I think.  (:

    Thank you all!  Every one of your answers kept adding to the explanation and really helped clear up this nagging confusion up.  Thanks a bunch to you all for your well-thought-out answers!

Pin It on Pinterest