-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
Glad you enjoyed it, Warden! And I love that profile picture. 😉
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
Yep! Feeling attachment to characters is really important for building reader engagement.
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
I’ll be tackling those questions in my article tomorrow, so I’ll avoid answering them here. 😉 But I’d love to hear your thoughts on tomorrow’s post!
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
The right ending can make or sink a book, so I’m 100% with you on the importance of endings!
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
That’s a fair point. I tend to believe this happens less for books than for other products (though there have certainly been several high-profile cases of authors who have done this), and most of the books I’ve found this to be the case for have enough glowing, long reviews that I think they were authentic. But certainly there will be some books…[Read more]
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
Part of that has to do with the market and what it takes to appeal to the most readers possible, but part of that I will attempt to answer in the next article. Glad that you’re enjoying it!
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
Thanks Eden! I’m glad it helped to spark some good thoughts on your end. 🙂
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
I’ve learned a lot through analyzing books I dislike to understand why people still like it despite its (seemingly glaring) flaws. Studying reviews is quite helpful as well. Hope you find the process illuminating!
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
Depending on what the cliche is, I agree. Certainly the examples he brings up are good indicators of this! The fact that most stories can be boiled down to nine basic plots is something that points rather strongly to the transcendent, IMO. Lewis gets into the popularity of cliches (especially cliched phrases) as well in Experiment in Criticism…[Read more]
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
There are some books that I avoid re-reading (particularly from my childhood, because I know I won’t be able to appreciate them anymore sadly. 😛
-
Josiah DeGraaf posted a new activity comment 7 years ago
Mmm–I think both of those are good questions. Regarding how often we read such books, I think it depends on our motive in reading bad books and what else we’re reading alongside it. I don’t think it’s foolish to read books that are more like candy if it’s part of a healthy diet–there are a fair number of those books that I read either because…[Read more]
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
Yep. I’ll delve into those a bit more in my follow-up article, but both of those elements are pretty important for writing an entertaining story!
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books? 7 years ago
I haven’t read “The Promised Neverland,” but agree with your general statement. It’s remarkably hard to create a 100% bad book and a book’s popularity often implies it’s doing something right (whether it has other major flaws or not).
-
Josiah DeGraaf wrote a new post 7 years ago
Why Do Readers Enjoy Objectively Bad Books?
Have you ever ordered a popular book and eagerly dove into it the day it arrived, only to discover it isn’t as amazing as it’s chalked up to be? It’ […] -
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, A Heretic's Sacrifice 7 years ago
That’s really encouraging to hear, Hannah. 🙂 Thanks for taking the time to mention this!
-
Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic The spoken word in the forum General Writing Discussions 7 years ago
@kayla-skywriter Like Zachary alluded to, while a lot of the principles of written storytelling will carry over to oral storytelling, thinking about your body language and voice is also really important as delivery will either make or break an oral story. I’d also recommend being flexible and being willing to “deviate” some from your original plan…[Read more]
-
Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic The spoken word in the forum General Writing Discussions 7 years ago
@kayla-skywalker Are you asking about how to write novels that also do well when read aloud, or how to craft good stories to tell aloud to others (even if they’re never written down)?
-
Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic *Smiles shyly* Hi, want to be friends? in the forum Introduce Yourself 7 years ago
@urwen-starial Sounds like you have a fair number of solid authors in your line-up. 🙂 I tend to write heroic fantasy (a middle-point between epic fantasy and low fantasy) and am currently working on finishing up my current WIP set in a world made up of airborne islands where two brothers need to learn to work together to overthrow their father as…[Read more]
-
Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic *Smiles shyly* Hi, want to be friends? in the forum Introduce Yourself 7 years ago
Hey @urwen-starial; welcome to the site! 🙂 Who are some of your favorite authors?
-
Josiah DeGraaf commented on the post, Dear Christian Novelists: Cleanness Is Not Next to Godliness 7 years ago
I would agree with your rule of thumb there, provided it’s in the context of Christ also being the one who inspired some pretty dark parts of Scripture, such as the conclusion of Judges. Ultimately, we ought to write to glorify God, not man, and I also agree that some Christian authors go too far on that front. I just read a submission a couple…[Read more]
- Load More













‘Entangle readers’. I like that phrase. I shall entangle readers, and they shall never escape. *evil laugh*
On a more serious note, I think it’s rare to find a popular bad book that’s 100% bad. Often there will be at least one good element that readers latch on to. For example, I found myself loving ‘The Promised Neverland’ despite its many flaws simply because the protagonist radiates goodness in a dark world.
I haven’t read “The Promised Neverland,” but agree with your general statement. It’s remarkably hard to create a 100% bad book and a book’s popularity often implies it’s doing something right (whether it has other major flaws or not).
I really enjoyed this… And agree very strongly. One thin I hate is loving a book, then reading a book that reshapes my reading appetite and going back to read the book I love only to discover where that it has weak spots…
There are some books that I avoid re-reading (particularly from my childhood, because I know I won’t be able to appreciate them anymore sadly. 😛
Turns out that you have more will-power than I do, Josiah. 😜
Good article, because I think there are books we come to find we enjoy for special moments. And then we realize that the events surrounding those moments we enjoy really aren’t so poignant.
Yep. I’ll delve into those a bit more in my follow-up article, but both of those elements are pretty important for writing an entertaining story!
Depending on what the cliche is, I agree. Certainly the examples he brings up are good indicators of this! The fact that most stories can be boiled down to nine basic plots is something that points rather strongly to the transcendent, IMO. Lewis gets into the popularity of cliches (especially cliched phrases) as well in Experiment in Criticism with some rather interesting insights.
A very thought provoking article! I loved reading this and I can’t wait to read the rest in the series.
Thanks Eden! I’m glad it helped to spark some good thoughts on your end. 🙂
I’ve learned a lot through analyzing books I dislike to understand why people still like it despite its (seemingly glaring) flaws. Studying reviews is quite helpful as well. Hope you find the process illuminating!
Part of that has to do with the market and what it takes to appeal to the most readers possible, but part of that I will attempt to answer in the next article. Glad that you’re enjoying it!
That’s a fair point. I tend to believe this happens less for books than for other products (though there have certainly been several high-profile cases of authors who have done this), and most of the books I’ve found this to be the case for have enough glowing, long reviews that I think they were authentic. But certainly there will be some books that fall into this camp.
The right ending can make or sink a book, so I’m 100% with you on the importance of endings!
Very interesting article! I will be sure to read the following articles.
Glad you enjoyed it, Warden! And I love that profile picture. 😉
Do you like 100 Cupboards?
Yep! Great book series. 🙂
I’ll be tackling those questions in my article tomorrow, so I’ll avoid answering them here. 😉 But I’d love to hear your thoughts on tomorrow’s post!
Yep! Feeling attachment to characters is really important for building reader engagement.
You’ve got me on the edge of my seat…I’m looking forward to reading the rest of the series!
I hope I’m not stepping on anyone’s toes, but I don’t like Hallmark movies. I’ll watch them if someone else in the room is watching them, but I wouldn’t voluntarily choose them unless I’m outlining the plot, analyzing the acting, making fun of them (a guilty habit that I should probably quit) or something like that. I’m genuinely curious about why people love them so much. To me, it seems like it’s the same plot and similar dialogue over and over again just with different actors. I will admit, I subtly enjoy the “Christmasy” aspect of the holiday Hallmark movies, but that’s about all I like about them. No hard feelings toward any Hallmark-lovers 🙂 I wonder…what aspects do these movies get right?
Thanks! The whole series is released now so you should be able to see it on the blog. 🙂
I’ve never seen any Hallmark movies personally, though I’m aware of their reputation. So I can’t unfortunately give great answers on that front, but my hunch is that they’re doing something right for a specific audience given their popularity.