fb

Activity

  • Daeus Lamb posted an update 8 years ago

    Hey @noahlitle, I happen to be working on a song project, writing lyrics for all of the 16 personality types. It’s going pretty well but I’ve gotten some critical feedback on the INTP one. Would you happen to be interested in giving an opinion?

    • @daeus-lamb Sure. I’m not sure how helpful I can be. I usually prefer instrumental music. But I am a musician, so maybe it’ll even itself out. 🙂

      • Hey, I didn’t know you were a musician. That’s cool.

        The music won’t be written for a couple weeks, so for now it’s just the lyrics. I asked four INTPs for their opinions and got these responses:
        1. It’s very INTP
        2. It’s too emotional/vulnerable. When pressed on what he meant, the guy said something roughly like, “It wasn’t helpful. It was like watching guys slash at each other.” I can’t remember his exact words and may have exaggerated them slightly. I’m not sure how much his personal mental/emotional wellbeing might have influenced this answer.
        3. The poetry is nice, but it feels too negative. Isn’t there something nicer you can say about this type?
        4. I don’t relate to it. (I have yet to receive any further details on this answer.)

        In light of these responses, I spent this morning making some edits. What would be most helpful is to know if the edits improve the song (particularly in making it more positive) and if you think the current version accurately depicts the INTP. It may be helpful to know that the stanza starting with “when the line gets tangled…” describes an INTP “in the grip”, a state of stress leading to them acting very out of the normal.

        Version #1

        Lord of a mental railway line that works around the clock
        Sending the trains to distant stations, I can never stop
        A million lines crisscross my mind. I travel every one
        Building the towns at every stop and satisfied with none
        A million lines would not suffice to describe this railway world
        Where rival thoughts are knocked about and countless theories hurled

        The steam that runs my engine is a tempest mixed with fire
        Pushing ever forward to where all my thoughts aspire
        The land of gold is always lurking past the next divide
        Promising to fill my soul. Has the promise lied?
        If I count the stars by name, aren’t the heavens still a void?
        My knowledge leaves me bloated, searching, cold, and paranoid

        Must I step down as railway captain? Is this job my own?
        Should I keep on roaming, or bring my treasures home?

        When the lines get tangled and my train shuts down. When I’m shoved
        Back and forth soon as I touch the ground. I’m not loved
        By these people; they all shout at me, “Oh, come on train captain
        Have you lost your mind?” Yes, I’ve lost my mind and I’m wrapped in
        Questions that are bound with emotions. Is there hope for me?

        I must step down as railway captain. The job is not my own.
        I can choose to keep on roaming or bring my treasures home

        Treasures abound in my railway world. I’ve just the one for you
        When your hand is on my shoulder it helps to get me through
        With a mind that pierces beyond where steam clouds try to hide
        If you’re looking to explore new worlds then I can be your guide
        I belong to the railway world, but also the world outside
        Trains were meant for exploring, but also to give a ride

        Version #2 (The current, edited version)

        Lord of a mental railway line that works around the clock
        Sending the trains to distant stations, I can never stop
        A million lines crisscross my mind. I travel every one
        I build the towns at every stop. My work is never done
        A million lines would not suffice to describe this railway world
        Where rival thoughts are knocked about and countless theories hurled

        The thrill of the ride gives me laughter; I cherish every view
        And love to chart out maps of all the lands I travel through

        The steam that runs my engine is a tempest mixed with fire
        Pushing ever forward to where all my thoughts aspire
        A gold mine will reward me over past the next divide
        I once thought it would fill my soul, but has the promise lied?
        If I count the stars by name, aren’t the heavens still a void?
        My knowledge leaves me stronger, yes, but sometimes paranoid

        Must I step down as railway captain? Is this job my own?
        Should I keep on roaming, or bring my treasures home?

        When the lines get tangled and my train shuts down. When I’m shoved
        Back and forth soon as I touch the ground. I’m not loved
        By these people; they all shout at me, “Oh, come on train captain
        Have you lost your mind?” Yes, I’ve lost my mind and I’m wrapped in
        Questions that are bound with emotions. Is there hope for me?

        I must step down as railway captain. The job is not my own.
        I can choose to keep on roaming or bring my treasures home

        Treasures abound in my railway world. I’ve just the one for you
        When your hand is on my shoulder it helps to get me through
        With a mind that tends to wander in a land that steam clouds hide
        If you’re looking to explore new worlds then I can be your guide
        I belong to the railway world, but also the world outside
        Trains were meant for exploring, but they can give a ride

        I’ll always be a railway captain. I guess I love the thrill
        And I’m eager for that good land lurking past the farthest hill

    • @daeus-lamb Awesome!
      I think this works pretty well. I was able to relate with most everything here.
      I kept wanting you to use the phrase “train of thought”. Do you avoid it on purpose?

      About the stanza you mentioned, I can relate to it, but the line breaks in the middle of the phrases bug me. It actually bugs me to the point of being distracting. I’m going to assume you did that on purpose? The music can smooth it out some, but I’m not sure if it could make me like it better.

      I did like the line: “Yes, I’ve lost my mind and I’m wrapped in Questions that are bound with emotions. Is there hope for me?”
      And: “My knowledge leaves me stronger, yes, but sometimes paranoid”

      #relatable XD

      Seriously, though. Knowing all the right answers is annoying sometimes.
      What if I have a legitimate question that I know the answer to? It HAS happened before.
      XD

      Some general thoughts:

      I have noticed that some of the most intellectual people are also somewhat emotionally unbalanced (myself included). It’s an interesting irony. These lyrics reminded me of that.

      I was thinking, “he’s got to get the music right if I’m going to like this.” Then I thought, “well, what would be a good model?” and “Last Train Home”, by Pat Metheny came to mind.
      I’m not sure it would be a good model, I just thought of it and had to recommend it. It’s a great song. 🙂

    • Ah, great! Glad it was relatable.

      My friend who’s writing the music was already talking about rewriting that one stanza with the enjambment so maybe we’ll do that.

      I don’t know why I didn’t use train of thought honestly. 😛 Maybe there’s still time to fit it in. I’ll have to take a look.

      Thanks for the song recommendation too.

    • I’m an ENFP and a guitarist. Probably shouldn’t bump in like this, but I wanna see where this goes.

Pin It on Pinterest