fb

Activity

  • K.M. Small replied to the topic The Morality of Pathos in the forum General Writing Discussions 6 years, 11 months ago

    @naiya-dyani

    I don’t fully have an answer for this, but I can say I’ve struggled with the same question quite a bit. It got to the point where I’ve temporarily stopped reading YA novels (which are full of these “emotional rewards”) until I understand the issue more fully. It feels like an unhealthy emotional indulgence, and I’m trying to figure out just what it is that creates that; I’ve read other novels that certainly have emotion, but it feels more rightly ordered than what I find in some other novels.

    Just to put the question into context, I’m wondering if you find yourself feeling this way only when reading a particular genre? For instance, is it mainly just in young adult books, or is it even in stories like Lord of the Rings?

    In general, I think pathos is meant to aid a story’s message by speaking to the reader on an emotional level in addition to an intellectual level. When we experience something emotionally, we often tend to be more impacted than if we understand it intellectually. For instance, in the Iliad, (spoiler alert) we may be able to grasp in our minds that Hector is dead. But because the Iliad is a story and utilizes emotion, we’re moved a lot more by the feeling that Hector is dead than the fact, if that makes sense. Because of the pathos of the story (and that scene), the message of the story is more impactful. However, I do think that pathos can be overused until it becomes — as you said — the story itself.

    I might have more thoughts on this later, but I’m curious as to what other people have to say 🙂

Pin It on Pinterest