fb

Activity

  • Lynn Renard replied to the topic Happy Endings in the forum Announcements 7 years, 9 months ago

    An example of a happy ending that cost too much is Girl in the Red Hood, by Brittany Fitcher. The protagonist, Liesel, is both unhappy and in unhappy positions throughout the majority of the story. Major spoilers ahead!

    1. Her father rips her and her mother from her grandparents.
    2. The village to which they relocate deliberately kills her mother.
    3. Her father is a drunk and nearly kills her out of neglect.
    4. The entire village gives her the cold shoulder for several years and won’t tolerate any talk of her leaving.
    5. When her father starts to turn over a new leaf, she watches a wolf rip out his throat.
    6. After she finally flees for a couple years, she’s still so traumatized that it barely registers when magic yanks her back.
    7. Her one childhood friend informs her she now must marry him whether she wants to or not.
    8. She finds out that that marriage will suck away her life force, killing her in a couple decades.
    9. Her and her fiancé’s weeks-long attempt to break the curse fails amidst long-drawn-out teenage angst.
    10. When they finally DO break the curse, every single character is mourning the death of some various loved one.
    11. Some people actually LIKED the curse and are mourning its breaking.
    12. Liesel’s now-husband gets moody at random intervals because he can still feel the curse clawing at his insides, apparently.

    There’s the occasional happy moment where Liesel and her childhood friend simply enjoy each other’s company. And right before her father’s death, he shares a happy memory of him and her mother. And at the end, Liesel and her husband fulfill a promise to go see the ocean together. (Spoilers done!) And, basically, that’s it: occasional moments of relative happiness pocketing a book of trauma and angst. o_O

    “Helping to close the circuit” is definitely a mark of a good happy ending – I agree! I think balance is crucial. Good stories need sacrifices and need to acknowledge those sacrifices, but stuffing sacrifice after sacrifice down the throats of the characters and the readers without sufficient payoff leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

    One story with a bittersweet ending that worked for me was K.M. Shea’s Endings – the seventh and final book in a King Arthur retelling. The series premise is that a 21st-century American girl, Britt Arthurs, gets zapped back in time to play the role of King Arthur because the real Arthur ran off with a shepherdess, and Merlin needs a specific kind of stand-in. (Spoilers ahead!) Britt finds out that Merlin’s time-travel spell froze her body’s aging mechanism, so she’ll basically have to spend the rest of her life watching her loved ones grow old and die. Then, just a handful of years into her reign, a battle severely wounds her, and her friends send her back to the 21st century for medical help, so she’s cheated out of even a few decades with the loved ones she made in Camelot – or so she thinks. After I think about a year of struggling to get back into her modern life, Merlin and a handful of others from Camelot show up, having given up their lives in Camelot to time-travel to her time, effectively turning all of them ageless in the process, too. So even though Britt gave up Camelot and mortality, she has loved ones that voluntarily did the same so she wouldn’t be alone. Also, it helps A LOT that Britt is never a whiny hero. She finds a way to really LIVE no matter her circumstances.

Pin It on Pinterest