fb

Activity

  • Josiah DeGraaf replied to the topic Such a Thing As Biblical Magic? in the forum General Writing Discussions 6 years, 1 month ago

    Here’s my personal opinion on the topic.

    In order to answer this question, I think we need to first answer another question: “What is magic?” Here’s why I ask this. If I told you a story about a man who went around incinerating armies with columns of fire, controlling the weather, and creating bread out of nothing, you would probably describe that man as a magician. But that description also matches the description of Elijah that we get in 1 and 2 Kings!

    So let’s think about how the Bible uses the word—because I don’t think the Bible uses the word “magic” in the same way that the fantasy genre always uses the word. Why is magic condemned in the Bible?

    I’d argue that the reason that magic is condemned is not because it is wrong to interfere with the natural order. The prophets did that all the time after all. (And certain things we do today to interfere with the natural order would have been called “magic” in that world.) The reason I believe God condemned magic in the Old Testament is because he was condemning those who went to demonic forces to gain power over the natural order. That’s why the magicians, sorcerers, and fortunetellers were all forbidden: God didn’t want the Israelites going to false gods to gain power over the natural world—he wanted them to come to him.

    In this world, the Bible teaches that going to supernatural beings who are not God for supernatural power is wrong—people should be going to God and God alone for this. But let’s say you create a fictional world where the divine being of that world created a magic system as a “new law of physics” or where people could use magic without entreating demonic entities for help. Is that the same thing as the type of magic that God forbids? I would argue that it isn’t, since I believe the Bible is referring to power that stems from demons—not to any type of supernatural power (since many of the prophets exhibited that power as well).

    As a result, unless your story is portraying characters who go to demons for magical powers in a good light, I don’t think OT admonitions about witchcraft are terribly applicable. And I’d largely agree with the value of @r-m-archer‘s distinctions.

    Now, all that being said, certainly some things that are fine can become sinful to those with a weak conscience. If as you’re reading books about magic, you find yourself tempted to believe that the story is real or that you should go to sources that are not God in the real world to gain magical powers… it may be better for you not to keep reading. If you aren’t tempted in that way, however, I personally believe authors are able to do so with a clear conscience.

    There are a variety of different perspectives on this question within the Christian community and you should test my argument here against Scripture as you will with any other argument you receive.But this is my personal response to this question. (:

Pin It on Pinterest