-
Audrey Caylin replied to the topic CD Week 17: negative arcs {discussion} in the forum Annual Theme Discussion 7 years, 9 months ago
@karthmin I may have to go read through some previous discussions to fully understand what you’re saying here, but I’ll try my hand at finding some examples.
I immediately thought of Heathcliff from Wuthering Heights as I was reading through all this (I apologize for any spoilers 😛 ). He starts out as a pretty dark character, but in years after he leaves Cathy, his morality takes an extreme turn for the worse. In general, I think Heathcliff fits in the second category of negative arcs, where his mindset takes a negative turn (as he becomes more obsessed with Cathy), but his skills take a positive turn as he goes off and gains a lot of wealth and prestige. Even after Cathy dies, he continues to grow in power over his estate, and his mindset keeps faltering morally as he works tirelessly to wed his son to Cathy’s daughter.
I sort of forget the ending, but I think his overall success or failure is debatable. On one hand, he dies and is supposedly reunited with Cathy. On the other hand, it was a violent way to die and he seemed completely unhappy, so I’d say that’s a failure. But in general, I think his arc fits into the second category.
I also thought of Boromir and Denethor from LoTR. I think I’d need to reread the series to really take in their change, as I don’t think either of them really fit into any of the categories. Boromir is slightly different, since he does nearly repent before his death, but otherwise his mindset change is negative and his ability seems to stay the same. Denethor is fascinating as he’s sunken so deep into despair that, in the strict sense of the word “ability” he has lost his cognitive power to think sanely and even govern, so perhaps he’s in the last category.
Those examples were a bit messy, but I think the one with Heathcliff was a bit clearer… negative arcs really are interesting topics to discuss, especially because there aren’t quite as many in literature now as there once were.












