fb

Activity

  • Steward of the Pen replied to the topic Fantasy Novella Alpha Readers Needed! in the forum Critiques 7 years, 9 months ago

    @taylor-clogston

    Ack! I’m so sorry it took me ages to get back to you on your story. *headdesk* I fully intended to do it weeks ago, but time ran away from me and left me tied to a chair. 😛 Anyway, I am finally here! I will try to answer all your questions by topic below.

    First… wow, that was deep. I found it quite engaging, but it was definitely a challenge for me to critique because of its depth. (This may be why you were having trouble getting feedback.) I had to reread some parts several times before I felt I understood what was going on because of all the symbolism and foreshadowing.

    Does it feel like it would lead to something interesting?

    Yes, I think it has the potential to lead to future books that are interesting. Although there was resolution to the immediate problem of bringing back the sun, Circe is gone and Chaos isn’t totally defeated. So there is definitely the suspense of wondering whether Chaos will return, or if the other Lords and Ladies will fall to the same fateful corruption as Circe.

    Are the characters are engaging?

    I thought the characters of Artorius, Jacob, and Circe were quite well developed and engaging. Jacob and Circe especially had strong and vivid personalities that fit their roles very well. Artorius wasn’t quite as interesting as those two, but his character voice was good in that the prose definitely gave it a refined, “lordly” feel that was appropriate for his character. At times, though, I think he felt a bit dry and emotionless. One place in particular where you could easily add in a lot more emotion is when he is thinking back to how Circe fell. I did like his display of affection and emotion when she died in his throne room and he was grieving over who she used to be. Some more of that depth of emotion throughout the book would make him more relatable, as the MC whom you want your readers to feel for. In the beginning when he still doesn’t have his memories, it’s understandable that he wouldn’t experience emotions about his past. But I’m sure he still would experience a lot of terror and confusion as Timothy, especially after his monotonous, blurry, uneventful days at the asylum.

    Plot: Is there too little going on to interest anyone?

    I thought that, overall, the plot was well paced and engaging. There were several places that were slow, but they served their purpose as reaction scenes and were necessary for the story. In other words, there wasn’t a ton of wordy description fluff in scenes with nothing going on that make the reader yawn, and it wasn’t so fast paced from jumping straight from action scene to action scene that the reader is left dazed and confused. I think you balanced it well. *thumbs up* I was definitely interested the whole way through, and never found myself skimming sections because of boredom (which I often do—a nasty habit :P).

    Worldbuilding

    I’m not sure what to expect for a world like this because it’s quite different from the sub-genres of fantasy I read and write, with a much heavier focus on the weird magic than I’m used to. As far as the magic system goes, I think the worldbuilding was quite extensive and complicated. At the beginning of the story I was a bit confused about how it worked, especially Artorius’ ability to “jump” from one place to another, particularly in chapter two when he first entered Acheron’s library. By the end, though, enough had been revealed that I understood what was going on, but didn’t fully understand it (which is good—I think magic systems that can be fully understood are kind of boring :P). Plus, for me, the mystery about the magic was definitely part of the suspense that kept me reading.

    The Chaos creatures were quite creative and well described, so those definitely added some memorable uniqueness to the world. On the other hand, I get the sense that other than the Lords and Ladies, the world is empty. Are there any creatures that aren’t under Chaos’ rule? And if not, were there ever any in the past? I know Artorius mentioned that he had sacrificed innocent lives, but were these just mortal beings who were passing through the world temporarily? If the Lords and Ladies are rulers under Order, who are they ruling over? What lives are at stake in this war other than those of the Lords and Ladies? What is the landscape like? I only got a vague sense of there being some forest and hills. Is there any vegetation? I would think it would all be dead or dying due to the persistent twilight. These are some questions that came to my mind as I was reading that you might consider answering to give the worldbuilding more completeness.

    Theme

    The themes that I see are pride, selfishness, sacrifice, and corruption (and obviously, good vs. evil). The main theme seems to be pride, demonstrated by Artorius’ unwillingness to let go of his right to the throne and power. Because of his pride, he’s unwilling to sacrifice his right or his life for the sake of righteousness. As a result, he’s unworthy to carry out what he believes he was chosen for. I think the theme is the most clear in the scene with the Undying One when the child said, “…So long as one man or woman, Lord or Lady or mortal, is willing to put aside their right for the sake of righteousness, then Order will stand.”  He’s self-righteous since he believes his rejection of Chaos makes him more worthy than his siblings, but fails to realize he’s made an idol of himself. If this was your main theme, you did a good job of reinforcing it in the final battle scene when Jacob makes a last minute self sacrifice and the sun returns. That was an unexpected plot twist which drove the theme home quite well.

    Is the protagonist’s closed? 

    I’m not entirely sure what you mean by “closed,” but if you’re asking if he has changed, meaning he has moved from one experiment in living to another, than I would say yes. He demonstrates in several ways at the end that he has let go of his pride; for example, he says he is asking for forgiveness (which he wouldn’t have before since he wouldn’t admit he was wrong), prays for wisdom and guidance (which before he would have said he already had, or didn’t need), and admits that he doesn’t expect his siblings to trust him (whereas before, he would have declared himself the only one worthy of trust, since he hadn’t used the weapons of Chaos). The real test to whether he has changed will be if he is later asked to sacrifice his life. It’s easy when the sun is shining (no pun intended) to be pleasant and on good behavior, but how will he react when conflict arises the next time? That’s where I would expect you to go with his arc in future novellas.

     

    Hope this helps you! I enjoyed reading it. You’ve got some good stuff here, so keep it up!

Pin It on Pinterest