-
Steward of the Pen replied to the topic Lesson 10: Sharing in the forum Annual Theme Discussion 8 years, 3 months ago
@ariella-newheart *winces with Evelyn* Yeah, I did that with my last book. My sub-plot didn’t make sense, and in order to fix it I had to add chapters, destroy some, change inconsistencies, and a whole lot of other pain. *wince.* I’ll never be a pantser again.
Fake deaths. *coughs awkwardly* Well, I suppose that depends on three things:
- Why did the character die? Or “die”? (read: writers, please stop killing characters just to shock the other characters and (maybe) the reader.)
- Why should the character return? (not because, (1) the writer just wanted to generate shock and didn’t actually want to kill the character, or (2) if the character did have a good reason to die but returned simply for a happy reunion.)
- Was the death believable? (I read one book once *cringe* where the MC “died” (she supposedly stopped breathing after being sick for a while) so her father would be grief stricken and have a change of heart, just before she started breathing again and later recovered completely. Sometimes someone simply disappears and everyone assumes they are dead with no proof, and the whole thing feels fake.)
It helps make it more believable when there are other deaths that are not fake. When no main characters are dying until the fake death, and then the character returns, it gives the impression that the main characters are invincible and nothing will happen to them, which destroys tension. I used a fake death in my last book, and I didn’t do a very good job making it believable. They’re pretty hard to pull off. Here’s a KP article that has a section on fake deaths at the bottom:
http://kingdompen.org/questions-to-consider-before-killing-off-a-character/
Don’t get me started on deaths in general 😛 You could listen to me rant about cliched deaths and unnecessary deaths and unemotional deaths and pushy emotional deaths all day. When done well at the right time to the right character, however, deaths are beautiful, powerful, and terrible all together. I think these articles explain everything for me:
http://kingdompen.org/three-ways-to-use-death-in-storytelling/
https://storyembers.org/three-reasons-you-should-kill-a-main-character/
https://storyembers.org/how-to-kill-characters-without-enraging-readers/
Anyway, those are my opinions 😉 By the way, can an anyone think of an example of a very well done fake death?












