-
Wordsmith replied to the topic Writing for money alone? in the forum General Writing Discussions 8 years, 2 months ago
I’ve been lightly following this discussion, so if this has already been said, please say so, but I don’t think it has been said explicitly.
It’s important to remember the myth of neutrality. There’s a reason it’s called a myth. There is no neutral ground, either someone is for Christ or they are against him. Similarly in writing what we are either displaying truth or not, even if subtly.
If we are writing something that is not evil or crude or dismissive of Christ (suppression of the truth), it is going to be truth. When we write a comedy, even if it never mentions any title of God, or pushes in that direction it can be a wholesome story by portraying truths that God has given.
Remember that any truth an unbeliever uses is being borrowed from God.
So if I write a story about a man who shows certain truth in his life, but I portray him as a fallen human being, even if I never mention God, I am writing about truth. Now if I write about this man as an unbeliever if I portray him as perfectly fine person in the end with no need for anything else, am I ultimately writing truth at that point? Or am I supporting the blindness of man. If in the end the man is in a state of hopelessness though, and I don’t bring any resolution, I am speaking truth about mans state. He can do things that at least appear good, but from his POV there isn’t any faith in God, so I’m speaking truth if I show that he has no hope in the state wherein he lives.
So as a Christian writer, if I’m not writing truth, I am writing lies. I should hope that as a Christian truth will live in the story that I write, because of the grace of God.
I would say that the question is about what are we portraying? If we are portraying truth, even if not explicitly pushing the gospel message, and even if it’s just a tiny seed meant to make someone think, then it’d be fine.
But the moment truth stops flowing into our writing, maybe we should reevaluate our values. I would hope to never see a Christian writer putting lies into his story, whether on purpose or not, and for whatever reason.
So are we writing lies for money? Or are we writing truth for money? There is no in-between. Our writing can have both (because we are fallen humans not perfect yet), but I think we would all strive to put truth into our stories… Because every presentation of truth is a witness in one way or another.
The myth of neutrality really is a myth.
I hope that didn’t sound too rambley… and I hope it made sense. 🙂












