-
Chelsea R.H. replied to the topic Mental Illness/Disorders In Christian Fiction in the forum General Writing Discussions 7 years, 2 months ago
This is a great topic! I am very passionate about these sorts of things, particularly anxiety, PTSD and autism. I’m a dog trainer, which doesn’t seem to be immediately connected, but my hope is to specialise in psychiatric service dogs. And so I’ve been doing a lot of research and reading up on various mental illnesses and things like autism and ADHD. Of course, these illnesses have to be to the point that they are debilitating, so the sort of handler that has an anxiety dog is not the same as the “average” (if any of it can be called that) person with diagnosed anxiety, but the same principle applies I think.
To be honest, I have never seen a good portrayal of any sort of mental illness in Christian fiction. In fact, one of the only mental illnesses I’ve seen in Christian fiction is PTSD. Every rough Christian “Bad boy” was a soldier in his past and now suffers from “Shellshock”. I have done a lot of research on PTSD, especially the ways it manifested in a historical context (I write WW1 fiction) and I have never seen it portrayed in a way that seemed real and authentic in a Christian novel. According to Christian fiction, PTSD is simply flashbacks and nightmares that are immediately healed by accepting that they strayed from Jesus’ good path for them.
As a couple of people have already said, our minds and souls are linked. But neither one is purely responsible for PTSD, in my opinion, and so neither can really fully heal it either. Of course, I believe God could heal PTSD, just as he can heal cancer and brain injuries and everything else, but the fact is that he usually doesn’t completely take it away.
Having said that, mainstream media (I mainly have noticed it in YA novels) have been working on this a lot lately. There have been some really good books that deal with mental illnesses, specifically anxiety (let me just say, I have never been diagnosed with anxiety and I would never say I have it, but out of all mental illnesses, it is the one I relate to the most. I am almost constantly worried about something, usually illogically) that have been published lately. Iron Man has sort of become an icon for his depiction of PTSD and i’m 100% sure Katniss Everdeen has PTSD as well.
But do Christians deal with it well?
Nope.
Having said that, I firmly believe that we can change. I do my best to give my characters realistic reactions to war and abuse, in some cases giving them PTSD and anxiety when it seems to fit the character. And obviously, a lot of you guys feel the same way and are trying to do the same.
Anyway…does this make sense? Am I just rambling?












