-
R.M. Archer replied to the topic Fantasy Is NOT the Same Thing As Magic in the forum Fantasy Writers 5 years ago
I don’t agree that Christian writers can never depict the supernatural. First of all, good literature is built upon truth. We must depict the world as it actually is (by which I do NOT mean fantasy worlds cannot be created with their own world building rules; rather, a Christian worldview must underlie it). We are not materialistic or naturalistic, depicting a universe devoid of anything spiritual or supernatural.All that to say, Christians must not promote witchcraft or depict it in a morally neutral manner. We do not condone or promote evil. But like R.M. Archer was saying, there is a difference between acknowledging evil exists and promoting it. It does not follow that we cannot acknowledge those things exist in fiction and we cannot call them out as evil. In 100 Cupboards by ND Wilson, there is a witch character who is very creepy and clearly portrayed as very, very evil. 100 Cupboards isn’t an explicitly Christian novel, but the author is a Christian, and that really shows in the book’s themes.
I agree with all of this.
I recently read a book called Recovering the Lost Art of Reading by Leland Ryken and Glenda Mathes, and there were some excellent chapters on what makes literature good, true, and beautiful. Their thoughts on ethics and portraying sin in fiction was super helpful and relevant to this discussion. Highly recommend it.Ooh, this one’s on my TBR.
I was going to respond to other pieces of your response, too, but then I realized I just agree with the whole thing. XD All things should be brought under submission to Christ, and there are ways to subvert pagan ideas to support Christian themes. We obviously can’t just take them as they are, but they can be used to further a Christian worldview rather than undermine it. I wholeheartedly agree.
it is literally making a false religion and false gods, how does it get more anti-biblical than that?Again, there’s a difference between creating false gods with the intention of worshiping them and creating false gods for the purposes of a story.
But at this point I think it’s just a matter of conscience. If your conscience forbids you, by all means follow your conscience. I in no way mean to discourage that by putting forth the other side. My conscience is clear, so I have no problem carefully using these sorts of topics in my work in ways that I believe are in line with what Scripture teaches about them. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with either stance so long as they’ve been honestly reached through Scripture, which I believe is true of both our arguments.
I think a lot of it, at this point, comes down to what we believe about why the supernatural is forbidden in Scripture, and we just don’t appear to be coming from the same belief on that point. There’s nothing wrong with that (again, given that both have been developed from knowledge and study of Scripture), it just means we’re highly unlikely to come to the same conclusion of what is or isn’t acceptable in this area.
But I’ve really appreciated this discussion. It’s helped me work out some of my more specific thoughts on things, and I hope it’s been edifying for you (and those reading) as well. Thank you for bringing up the initial topic and being willing to bat arguments back and forth. 🙂
Hey everyone! I just joined this forum in search of some old friends I left on the Wingfeather Saga forum awhile ago…Oh hi! I recognize you! XD
I’m actually stepping out, but we’ve basically covered whether or not the word “magic” should be used solely to refer to supernatural powers as opposed to natural-to-the-fantastical-world powers; whether or not Christians should depict the supernatural; what counts as supernatural (since some stories blur the line between supernatural and natural-to-the-fantastical-world); whether or not fictional religions are acceptable in Christian works; what makes supernatural magic wrong… Um… I might be missing things, but I think those are the main points.












