-
R.M. Archer replied to the topic Fantasy Is NOT the Same Thing As Magic in the forum Fantasy Writers 5 years ago
So if I understand your point correctly, you’re saying that you agree that magic and supernatural things are sin, but it is fine to right if portrayed carefully as thing a person does in the book that is wrong, like any other sin such as murder, theft, lust, lying, etc…Is that correct?Correct.
First, it must be clear, beyond even a small doubt clear, that the magic or supernatural elements are evil, sin, and were mistake.Agreed.
In addition to this, I don’t think the magic/supernatural things should give any benefits, even temporary benefits (such as saving someone’s life) to the characters, because if it does, it will easily be confused with the normal way people use magic in books.I don’t think that’s necessarily the case so long as rule #1 is followed and the benefits are temporary and far outweighed by the consequences. Magic in the real world holds appeal to people because it’s perceived to have a benefit, therefore to omit any such benefit in a fictional portrayal seems dishonest to me. But that benefit definitely ought to be fleeting and not worth the cost, and I think it’s still possible to keep supernatural magic distinct from common-use “magic” with that balance (or… lack thereof, I suppose, since they oughtn’t be balanced).
Also, I wouldn’t recommend having a main protagonist use magic, even in a clearly sinful, unhelpful, and damaging way, because it could confuse the reader, seeing that they are after all, the protagonist.Eh… I can definitely see reasoning for this, and I don’t intend to have my protagonists dabble in anything like this if/when I include it in my books. However, I can also see a benefit to showing the protagonist stumble in this just as any other sin (again, under the assumption that it is portrayed as clearly wrong and as having consequences), since readers stumble into sin and I can see how it might be helpful to follow a character who fails and then realizes their failure, suffers the consequences, and grows from it and leaves it behind. But, again, I can see arguments for both sides of this particular point and I don’t wholly disagree with your initial statement. I can see a potential danger in the protagonist using it as clearly as I can see a potential benefit, and the danger ought to outweigh the benefit at least until very careful and thorough thought and consideration and prayer has gone into a decision the other way.
Lastly, I just want to make sure we agree that the way you are describing magic to be used, is not the way people (such as Sanderson, Rothfuss, and Riordan) use it in books, they use it as a totally okay ability or power that has side effects, which, it seems, you might actually agree with me that it is unbiblical to write. Do you agree with that? That things like Harry Potter are bad to right?I’m not sure I’m following your classification. I’m not familiar with Rothfuss, so I can’t say one way or the other there. Riordan’s and Sanderson’s books I think would both fall into the grey area @taylor-clogston was describing in which the powers are intrinsic and natural to the world, but also connected to the supernatural, and there’s no clear distinction (and as they’re fantasy worlds, I would argue that they needn’t ascribe to exactly the same laws of distinction. If the god(s) of a given fantasy world have designed that world in such a way that people naturally have powers beyond what would be expected, whether they’re purely natural or have hints of that world’s supernatural, that’s very different to my mind than a world in which characters manipulate the supernatural to gain powers as in the real world). Harry Potter, on the other hand, bears enough similarity to the real-world and its magic that it’s much more iffy. So I’m not sure where we agree or disagree on this point, since I think we’re categorizing things differently.
You’ve really got me thinking about whether I’d ever write a book with magic in that way Miss Archer. xD You have to be extremely careful and clear that it is bad, that’s the gist of my answer I guess.That’s cool to hear. I like making people think. XD We do at least agree on the gist of it, lol.












