-
Cathy replied to the topic Stories and Fantasies in the forum Fantasy Writers 5 years, 7 months ago
Thank you for critiquing me!
I was pretty vague in showing a lot of what was going on, I tend to get so involved in what it feels like I forget to explain what it actually is lol. I feel like this is a prologue to something but I want it to be able to stand on its own. I think about a girl stuck in a fairy tale book trying to break out of her role in the story by killing the wolf who symbolizes fear but also the internal lies she’s believed about herself. But I definitely didn’t establish that well in the narrative. Alright, so pounding that out in the story.
The Beast is the next fairytale in the book so somehow related but if I want this to stand alone I might need to cut that out or at least clarify better like you pointed out. And the rose…mhmm, I only have a vague idea what it’s supposed to be, I think it’s desire and picking the right rose is finding realistic dreams or making those over-idealized desires concrete and brought back to what can be done; taking a fairytale ending and making it practical. I better find a way to better integrate that in the story. And you’re right a lot of my sentences are cluttered and confusing, that’s another thing I need to pound out.
Alright! I’m gonna redraft that with your advice and see how that improves…
Thanks again, that really helped me!Doing this literally right before work but since when has time management been a skill of mine…Lol, I’ve literally started jotting story notes in the middle of a test before.
Alright what I see is first of all; it’s got excellent descriptions I can really get a feel for these characters and they’re interesting and exciting! Buut, there isn’t much plot information and maybe packing all the descriptions into one scene might strain the read. Maybe go right to Alexander Northiron falling into the river, or have the two characters doing something like talking or setting up for the action while you describe them. The way you describe them is scrumptious and provokes a very clear image both of them and their personalit–IRONSTONE like the Ironflow River! Brendin mentioned being involved in…wait is Ada Warin his sister?! *haha, it’s a good thing I don’t like reread all these posts while studying for my science tests*
Anyway, critiquing; the descriptions are luxurious but impractical all at once especially in an action/adventure novel (I’m assuming it’s action/adventure?). Try incorporating dialogue or interaction with the scenery that builds up to Alex (assumably) drowning. <3












