-
Cathy replied to the topic Stories and Fantasies in the forum Fantasy Writers 5 years, 8 months ago
Ooh, intriguing! Do you want critique or no? Great story (I had such a clear picture of what was going on, ha ha).Yes please critique me and be brutally critical! (Thanks, I had such a clear picture in my head)
Alright non-Middle-earth Part 1 critique! First of all, it’s really good and I can’t wait to see how you develop it!
I’m gonna just start with some staple questions I use with my writing to critique; 1. Who’s the main POV in this clip? 2. What’s the main problem in the scene? 3. What does the POV want/need? 4. What’s the main feel you want to convey? And 5. What changes to push the next scene?
So, for 1 you seem to start with Rhea but shift to Nayandi, maybe you should start with Nayandi instead or have a transitional element or give her a more distinctive voice? Describing things through a POV or an emotional tone can describe both the setting and the character’s personality by how she views the setting.
Number 2 the main problem/goal, seems on an emotional level Nayandi’s decision as a half-Elf, maybe you should set that on the forefront within the first couple paragraphs? Another problem they seem to be wrestling with is the forest, but why are they in the forest? You might not want to answer that immediately, if so, maybe you should give a sorta writer’s promise that there’s something definite and purposeful about path; focus on hinting at goals and reasons so the reader knows this is building to something. So 3 is pretty much answered in this too unless there’s another, more steady internal want/need to be addressed in the story as a whole so 4;
The main feeling seems to be how chilling the forest is the key words coming to mind are; isolation, impending doom, and memory, memory being the transition from this scene to the next scene? And 5 the change idk but it’s probably not necessary for every scene. So…I lost my train of thought XD. I like it and I can’t wait to see what happens next. Maybe focusing on one POV for each scene would make the narrative smoother? But that’s just me <3(welp, that was a horrible critiquing of mine XD )












