-
Kristianne Hassman replied to the topic Ninjanaria Chapter Three: Ninjanaria đ in the forum Fantasy Writers 6 years, 3 months ago
Here’s my critique:
Timâs eyes flashed around the room. Where am I? He could remember sinking, losing all sense of direction, then all of a sudden emerging into⊠somewhere. He didnât remember much. (Just to be clear, maybe you should change it to, “He didn’t remember much else.”)There was a window looking out over a vast lake, a dresser
stoodon his left and a bookshelf, full of old leather-bound books to his right. Just then a middle-aged woman entered the room. She had long black hair and a pleasant face. She smiled. âAw (I think you mean “Ah”), your awake.â Her voice was smooth and low. âWeâve been waiting. Throden is eager to see you.â–Why is Throden eager to see him? Maybe clarify.Tim frowned. He didnât understand what she was talking about. Should I know this person? âUm, who are you again?â
She laughed. âIâm Sringard, and youâll meet Throden in a moment,â she answered. âHe found you by the pond unconscious and brought you here so I could take care of you.â Tim was confused. Whereâs Jered, and Keren, andâŠand, Ana!?
âWhere is my family?â he asked anxiously. She smiled kindly. âYou must have a lot of questions. Iâll send Throden up and he can answer them. I have to finish dinner.âThen she turned and walked out closing the door softly. Tim lay there for a minute, lost in thought. Maybe I floated downstream when I fell into the pond? But the pond didnât have any stream to float down. (Maybe change to “But the pond didn’t have any streams flowing out of it”) He climbed stiffly out of bed and walked to the window. His head hurt, but not terribly. He realized his clothes had been taken from his body and in their place, was a long white robe. The sun was setting and it took his breath away at how beautiful the water was. There was a light knocking at the door then a man entered. He was tall and very fit. –The word “fit” feels a little obscure. Maybe use something more specific like “muscular” or “lean.”
His face was stern but not unkind. Must be the thing, knock, and enter without permission. He (replace with “Tim” to clarify who’s thinking) thought dryly. âAre you Throden?â he asked. The man smiled. âYes, thatâs me. And you are?â
Tim smiled back. âIâm Tim.â He held out his hand. Throden reached out, as if to shake Timâs hand, but instead grabbed his forearm. (Ooh, nice detail!)
âNice to meet you.â Turning around, Throden grabbed a chair and sat down. âYou probably have a lot of questions.â–Why would Throden assume Tim has lots of questions if he doesn’t know yet that Tim isn’t from Ninjanaria? And wouldn’t Throden want to know first who Tim is and how he got here?
Tim took a deep breath. In fact, he had so many questions he didnât know where to start.âYeah, so I guess first off, where am I?â âOh, another outsider I see.â Throden smiled. You are in the great town of Urit,â he answered.
Tim racked his brain, he conjured up all the geography lessons he had ever taken, but Urit, didnât ring any bells. âIâm sorry, could you be more specific? My geography was never very good.â Throden laughed. âSure, weâre just south of the town of Brarlock.â Brarlock? Still didnât ring any bells.
He laughed nervously. âWhich country?â He asked. Throden shrugged. âWe mostly go by towns here. You wonât find any countries until you head further north.â That just made him more confused. No countries? He laughed. He must be messing with me! âNo, but for reals, where am I?â Throden frowned. âI am being real. The countries are further north! Iâm not sure what you mean.â Tim could feel the color rising in his cheeks. He was becoming angry. âPlease stop messing with me,â he said calmly. âFor the last time, Iâm not messing with you! Your in the world Ninjanaria, if that helps.â He said sarcastically. –To me, this doesn’t feel sarcastic the way he says it. Maybe use another adverb to describe how he says it.
Tim studied his face. He really isnât joking! âWait youâre literally not messing with me!â Inside he felt a sinking feeling. Ninjanaria? How the heck did I get here? Throden frowned again. âYou mean you arenât from here?â he said. âLike your seriously not from this world?!â –Tim hasn’t yet said that he isn’t from Ninjanaria, so why would Throden assume that he’s not?Â
Tim didnât know what to say. He felt like this was all a hoax, but Throden⊠Either he was really good at lying, or he was sincere. Both theories were possible, but something inside of Tim told him Throden was telling the truth. Somehow he was in another world.
âDo you have siblings? Throden asked. –Why would this be the next question he asks Tim? I would think he would want to know more about how Tim got here than about his family. Maybe he’s thinking of the prophecy, but to me it just feels like he’s being conversational.Â
Tim was shocked, he hadnât expected that. –“Shocked” feels a little strong. And why wasn’t he expecting this question?
âUh yeah, I have three. Why?â Throdenâs face suddenly changed. âThree? What are their names?â âKaren, Jered and Ana,â he answered. âBut why is this important?â Throden stared out the window as if trying to remember something. âGet dressed and meet me downstairs. There are some clothes in the drawer over there,â he said pointing to the dresser. Then he ran out of the room leaving the door wide open. Tim stood there trying to take in all Throden had said. His mind reeled with all the things he had told him. He got up and walked to the dresser. Opening the doors he found, deerskin pants and tunic. He quickly traded the nightgown he was wearing for them and peeked his head out the door. The hall was empty, but he could hear voices coming from below. He stepped into the hall and walked toward what he thought were the stairs. He was right, and he stopped to listen. But he could hear only their voices and not their actual words. He sighed and walked down the stairs. He emerged into what must have been the kitchen. Sringard had her back to him, and was just taking hot golden-brown biscuits out if the oven. He could just see Throden sitting at a little table in the other room. âAm I in time for dinner?â
Sringard jumped, startled and almost dropped her plate of biscuits. âMy, child you nearly gave me a heart attack!â she exclaimed.
Throden looked up from polishing his staff and smiled. Tim laughed nervously before responding. âIâm sorry maâam.â Sringard laughed. âDonât apologize, and your dinner is on the table.â Tim walked over to the table and sat across from Throden, mumbling a greeting. âAw, finally. Iâve been starving down here while you snoozed away!â Throden said. Then more loudly, âCome on Sringard Iâm starving!â âComing!â she called back. And very soon came bustling out of the kitchen with a hot plate of steaming biscuits. Setting them on the table, she reached over and lifted the lid off a ginormous (“enormous”) cast iron pot, revealing a pot roast with carrots and potatoes. Tim sighed with pleasure. It felt like forever since heâd eaten.
***
Jered slowly opened the letter. He almost didnât read it. He still hadnât forgiven his dad for leaving. Why did you go? The question haunted him. He wondered why his mom had had the letter. Was she hiding something? The letter dated, November 19th, 2019. Just a week before he died, Jered realized. He took a deep breath. I can do this!
Dear Jered, Iâm being hunted. So I had to write you this letter before I died. I was once fromâŠ..wellâŠ..from a different world, called Ninjanaria. Donât laugh Jered, Iâd never lie to you. Where I come from, there was a prophecy concerning you, your siblings, your cousin and something else called a Murry. It was said you would save Ninjanaria from a terrible darkness. When I first heard about the prophecy I had no idea it was about my own children you see. I was sent from the Council of Ninjas to find you.. but I found your dear mother first and staid on earth. Then, when we started having children, I forgot about the prophecy, pushing it to the back of my mind. Only recently did I start thinking about it again. And only recently did the Graylick start hunting me. So I had to leave my dear family behind. I could never go back to Ninjanaria and give up my children. Nor could I stay with you and put you all in danger. Please understand I did what I did to protect you and not to hurt you. I love you so much! Love, Your Dad
Jered gasped. How is this possible? Thinking about it made him sick to his stomach. Then it hit him. Thatâs where Tim is! Heâs stuck in a different world, just like I thought. —Why did he think Tim was stuck in another world? Maybe I missed something from an earlier chapter? And why would he immediately assume from his dad’s letter that Tim went to this world? This feels a little unrealistic unless you give something beforehand that is convincing enough for Jered to connect the dots.
I have to go find him, heâs in danger! Putting the note in his back pocket he grabbed his backpack and started stuffing his clothes into it. He was angry at his mom for not telling him sooner. Walking down the hall towards the stairs he stopped in front of Karenâs bedroom. Should I tell her? Should I take her? He knew Keren would want to come, but he wasnât sure if she should. She has to stay here to help mom and look after Ana. He finally made up his mind to tell her, but not let her come.
***
Jered stood on the highway, his thumb in the air. He was trying to flag a ride to his cousinâs house. He had decided to tell him, and if he was willing, to take him with him. Keren took that pretty hard. He sighed. He had knocked on her door softly at first but harder when she still didnât wake up. Finally, he just pushed open her door and woke her up himself. He had felt pretty stupid telling her. But when she read the note she just burst into tears. It felt weird comforting her. Often times he would be the one crying on her shoulder, in the weeks following his dad dying. –This seems a little uncharacteristic of a boy Jered’s age.
He had never seen her cry, mostly in support of his mom. He guessed she must have cried before but he had never witnessed it. She would often hide places where she felt comforted not by any human but by nature and the things she knew so well. After that, he had written a note to his mom and Ana explaining things. Taking some food from the pantry he had headed out. Jered shook himself out of his thoughts, noticing an old, beat up, pickup stopping on the side of the road. âNeed a lift son?â The person asked. The face looked familiar. Then he remembered, it was an old friend of his dadâs. âYeah thanks, McCain!â he answered climbing in. –Is there a reason he calls him “McCain” and not “Mr. McCain” or his first name? It feels a little too casual and maybe even disrespectful for Jered to call an old friend of his father’s just by his last name.
âWhere you headed son?â âUp to my auntâs house,â he said. McCain brightened up but tried not to show it. –This feels like head hopping. You want your POV to be consistent. Maybe change it to “McCain brightened up a little, but it seemed to Jered like he was trying to hide it.”
âReally? That woman sure is a fine cook!â Jered laughed. âYeah she sure is,â he agreed. âSo what brings you out here all alone, without a ride and backpacking?â he asked curiously. Jered tensed. âNothing, just thought Iâd visit my cousin.â Well, Iâm not lying. âAt four oâclock in the morning?â McCain asked skeptically. Jered tried to laugh it off and changed the subject. âSo where are you heading?â McCain looked sideways at him. âSon are you in trouble?â Jered stiffened. Should I tell him? After all, he was a friend of dads⊠Finally coming to a decision, he said. âMcCain, you knew my dad really well, right?â McCain smiled. âThat I did, a good man he was too. You remind me a lot of him, a very handsome face.â Jered shrugged the compliment off. âOkay, then read this letter.â he handed it to him. âI would be glad to,â he said. âBut I canât when Iâm driving, here you read it to me.â and he handed it back. Jered swallowed and started to read. When he was done, he looked at McCainâs face. It was wrinkled in concern and sympathy. âWell,â he said. âI already knew about all that, I didnât think he would have told you about it though.â –It feels a little too convenient that McCain would just happen to pick Jered up as he’s going to his cousin’s house and then that he knows about Ninjanaria too. I would suggest introducing us earlier on to McCain so that it doesn’t feel too convenient for him to be here at this time.
Jered was confused. âYou already knew about Ninjanaria?â he asked. âYes I did, and I also swore to him I would never tell any of you about it,â he said. âMcCain, my brothers in there.â McCain gasped. âWhat!?â –It feels a little uncharacteristic of McCain to gasp and exclaim like that. I would show his surprise in another, more subtle way. Also, why would he immediately believe Jered? After all, Jered doesn’t know for sure that his brother is there. And honestly, it’s a wild idea! đ It would feel more realistic if he questioned Jered about it and tried to propose some other explanation.
âThatâs why Iâm going to my cousinâs house. I need his help finding him,â he said. âWell, in that case, we need to hurry,â he said and he stepped on the gas.
***
15-year-old Jaylin Storm, laid in bed thinking to himself. What am I doing here? Why havenât I run away yet? He was angry at himself and confused. Those were the question he asked himself every night just before drifting off to sleep. My dad hates me, my mothers gone! Why do I stay here?Â
But even as he asked himself those questions he knew the answers. Heâs stayed in that little house at the edge of Brarlock for one reason. His brother. Through all the years of hardship and pain, Hougen had always been there for him and he knew he couldnât leave him there alone. –Show us why he’s running away now. Why has he not run away before? What has happened this time that makes him decide to run away? Show us how his dad hates him. Show us his nightmares.
Why wonât Hougen come with me? He asked himself angrily. Jaylin tossed and turned in his bed trying to fall asleep, but thoughts of his life and what his life could be, kept him awake gnawing at him like a hungry lion devouring its prey. He tried to imagine his mother. What would life be like with her? Would she love him, would she care for him like he had always dreamed she would? His mother had died at his birth, and his dad had blamed him ever since. Jaylin could feel the tears creeping up and tried to push them back. He didnât want to cry, but he couldnât stop himself. Soon hot tears were streaming down his cheeks, touching his lips with their salty moister. Throwing back the covers, he grabbed his cloak off the bedpost and ran out the door heading outside. He was openly sobbing now. He was running, dodging trees, jumping ditches. He didnât know where he was going, but anywhere as long as he was going away from his home. Jaylin couldnât run anymore, stumbling to a stop he leaned against a tree gasping for breath. He slid down the tree suddenly too tired to hold himself up. He didnât care about himself anymore, if he died right then, right there he wouldnât have cared. âJust finish me off!â he screamed. Then he sunk into a fitful sleep. His dreams were filled with monsters, demons, and hungry creatures. Even in his dreams, he couldnât escape the feeling of being hunted. And in his dreams, he realized he needed to leave with or without Hougen. Jaylinâs eyes flew open. Something had awoken him but he wasnât sure what. Then crack a twig snapped. Iâm being watched by something, or someone, he realized. Early morning sunshine shone through the dense canopy above him, dappling the ground with patterns of gold and yellow.–This sentence doesn’t fit with the tone of the scene. It feels too warm and happy. You want to build the intensity and suspense as much as possible.
Jaylin spun around, confronting the thing that was watching him. There stood Hougen, only a few yards away. âThe heckl man you nearly gave me a heart attack!â Hougen laughed âYeah, wellâŠ..why are you out here anyway? I heard you leave last night.â Jaylinâs smile faded. âUmâŠyeahâŠI donât really want to talk about it.â He mumbled. He pushed past Hougen and headed in the direction of the house. âWhoa, dude,â Hougen said, stepping around Jaylin and blocking his way. âI know you donât want to talk about it.â He said. âBut sometimes you need to. Even I sometimes need to,â he added. Jaylin sat down. âAlright,â he grumbled, glaring at him. âIs it a girl?âHougen asked. Jaylin spat on the ground. âAbsolutely not! You know how I feel about girls,â he said. Hougen laughed again. âYes, I know. I was only teasing. But for real, whatâs on your mind?â he asked seriously. Jaylin sighed. âWell, itâs a little hard to explain,â he began. âBut I feel trapped, I feel like Iâm prey being devoured by a giant beast. But slowly like itâs letting me bleed out.â He stopped. âDoes that make sense?â Hougen looked at him concerned. âItâŠdoes,â he said slowly. âWhy do you feel this way?â he asked. Jaylin tensed, then after a long pause, âBecause of dad.â He answered softly, not daring to look into Hougenâs eyes. Hougen exhaled slowly. âYou need to leave,â he said after a little while. âWhaâŠ?â Jaylin was confused. âYou need to leave,â he repeated himself. âGo, get out of here, you canât stay here.â Jaylin looked his brother in his eyes and only saw regret and sadness there. âButâŠâ he stammered. âWhat about you?â This was what he had wanted, Hougen to want him to leave. But now that it was actually happening he started to doubt himself. Could he even make it by himself? Where would he go? âJaylin!â Hougenâs voice snapped him back to the present. âWait here Iâll go pack a backpack for you. It would be best if you didnât come back to the house,â he said. Jaylin nodded. âOkay,â he said. âIâll be here.â –Why wouldn’t he question Hougen more about why he’s suddenly demanding that he leave?
Jaylin sat there waiting. It had been about 40 minutes since Hougen had left, and Jaylin was getting worried. Suddenly Hougen appeared, carrying his backpack and a steaming plate of eggs and bacon. âI thought you might need these,â he said, handing him the plate. Jaylin took the plate gratefully. âI hoped youâd be smart enough to do that,â he said and laughed. Hougen smiled. âIâll miss you, you know,â he said. Jaylin looked up. âI know. Iâll miss you too.â When Jaylin was done with the eggs, he set the plate on a stump and grabbed his backpack. They stood there in silence for a moment just looking at each other. Then Hougen stepped forward and gripped Jaylin in a bear hug. âStay safe,â he chocked out. Then grabbing the plate he walked off towards the house. Jaylin watched his brother, who had become his best friend over the years, leave. Will I ever see him again?
***
Marrill stood, looking at the ruckus going on in the schoolyard. She was glad she was not caught up in the middle of it all like she usually was. No, not this time, this time another kid was all the trouble. Marrill laughed, happy the next day was not a school day. She rushed through the plans of tomorrow in her head. Tomorrow, she was free. Just then, she heard the familiar sound of the school bell ringing out over the yard. End of lunch, she told herself and started to trudge down the little dirt path. She pushed thoughts of tomorrow out of her mind and prepared herself for her afternoon classes. When she got to the schoolhouse door, she was the last person in. Marrill walked home, happy she didnât have to stay in detention like she normally had to. She could just walk home straight from school. A group of kids stood in front of her blocking the sidewalk. âHey guys,â she said spying some of her friends in the group. She also spied Ricky in the group and decided not to stay and chat, she didnât want to talk to him. âHey,â a couple of them said and stepped out of her way. But Ricky fell in step beside her. She sighed. âWhat are you doing.â Ricky shrugged. âNothing,â he said. âJust thought Iâd see what you were doing.â âRicky, I already said I donât like boys and donât want to go out with you,â she said trying to be as nice as she could. Ricky stopped. âWhy Marrill?â he asked. âWhy donât you like boys? Not all boys are selfish, grimy, hotheaded, pigs like Steven!â She laughed at his impression of Steven. âI know Ricky, but my parents would never allow me to go out with a boy, Iâm only 13.â Ricky sighed. âOh,â he said and shuffled his feet awkwardly. âPlus we might be moving,â she added. She didnât really believe they were actually going to move but she used it as another excuse. Ricky looked up startled. âWhat!?â he said. âYour moving?â She nodded. âProbably.â He slumped his shoulders in defeat. âI see,â he said. He started to walk off, then stopped and looked over his shoulder at her. âDo you want to write to each other when you move?â he asked. Marrill had not expected that. âUmâŠsure why not?â she said and laughed awkwardly. Ricky brightened up instantly. âCool, Iâll bring you my address tomorrow,â he said. âOkay,â she said. âSee ya.â Walking home she wondered, why did I just agree to that?
Just one thing I want to mention: Four POV shifts in one chapter is a little confusing. Maybe you should consider putting only one or two different POVs in a chapter. That would make it less confusing.
Other than that, great job! I’m really intrigued to find out what happens next. đ












