-
Allison Grace replied to the topic Weekly Wonderings in the forum Erekdale Writing Discussions 7 years, 7 months ago
Great question! I agree with Karthmin on his two points.
Daeus’ article on writing violence has some good points too. https://storyembers.org/how-should-christian-authors-depict-violence/
As I was reading that article the other day, I asked myself the question (and Daeus might have posed it, I can’t remember), “Am I writing violence because I find it entertaining or for shock factor?” I realized that I had been rather mean to one of my characters and it didn’t have any bearing on the story. So I changed a few things around to take out some of the violence.
So if the violence is not necessary to the plot and it’s just for shock/you just want to write it, take it out!Sometimes, violence is necessary to the story. (For example, in my book I need an execution.) I think it’s better to err on the side of lacking detail/description than going overboard. Your alphas/betas might be able to tell you that, “hey, that scene fell flat, you need more detail,” but you certainly don’t want to make them uncomfortable or disturb them.
When I write violence, I try to focus more on the character’s emotions. (One of my characters found his best friend dying in the woods. While I said there was blood and the friend had a knife in his chest, I didn’t describe much more than that. I focused on my character’s fear, desperation, sadness, etc. I think emotions connect to readers better than gore.)
Like Karthmin said, you need to keep your audience in mind. What might be violent to me might not bother you.
Now, I’ve watched Star Wars and the two Jurassic World movies and those get rather violent at times. I might not be the best person to ask about violence levels. When I’m reading, I rarely stop because of violence–I’m more likely to stop because of language, romance, poor writing, etc.
On Karthmin’s second point, be sure your darkness and violence points to something good.
For example (I’ll use my book again :P): My characters had to walk through a bad part of the city and there was this drunk guy in an alleyway harassing my female MC. My male MC stepped between them and defended her. I debated whether or not to keep the scene, but I thought, “the purpose of this scene is not to shock readers, it is to show my male MC’s honorable character.”All that being said, some of the best books I’ve read are “gritty.” I do think you need a bit of “real life” in your stories, but don’t ever glorify the evil. Don’t make it seem like it’s okay that the villain just murdered an entire village because “they were just peasants.” God created man in His image, therefore human life is sacred. (I know we might be talking about a fantasy here, but still, life is sacred.)
Don’t glorify sin. Yes, sin is real. Yes, this world is full of sin. But don’t make sin the focus of your story, use the darkness to point to the light. Show the consequences of a sinful choice, not the supposed “benefits.”
I hope that helped! Sorry I went off on a little rant there. 😀












