-
Rachel Rogers replied to the topic Beta Sun in the forum Critiques 8 years, 6 months ago
@brandon-miller HEY…! Maybe you should make the plant a wilted peppermint plant. I have mint plants on my desk because the scent helps with focus and clear thinking. Also because mint is pretty and hard to kill. However, mine may or may not be in need of some major TLC because life happens. 😛
The one comment I had apart from answering your questions had to do with dialogue. There’s a lot of dialogue, and a lot of it was short, back-and-forth type stuff and/or didn’t have dialogue tags…all of which is, of course, no problem on its own. However, I started feeling a little lost. Partly I think that’s because dialogue speeds up the pace? But it’s easy for readers (aka me…it’s easy for me lol) to get lost without dialogue tags. Sooo…there are basically three options that help readers keep up with who’s talking:
- Add more dialogue tags,
- Make sure the dialogue carries the character’s personality so obviously that dialogue tags aren’t needed for clarification anyway, or
- Tighten the dialogue so there’s less back-and-forth to get lost in to begin with.
For instance, phone conversations. There is a LOT of fluff in a real phone conversation, but you don’t really *need* most of it to tell a story. I read an article in Writers’ Digest a long time ago that suggested eliminating the fluff that we take for granted anyway. Consider the end of this conversation:
“Thanks, Christi.” You’re a life-saver.
“Any time.”
“Have a nice day.”
“You too.”
Too late. “Thanks, goodbye.”
“Bye!”
Click.
You could do something like this:
“You’re a life-saver, Christi.”
“Any time. Have a nice day.”
Too late. “Thanks, you too.”
Click.
Technically, most of the pleasantries are still there, even, because they’re carrying the theme of poor Sally’s rough day (bless her heart), but they’re consolidated, which I think keeps the rhythm a little smoother. The caveat here is that I have no idea what the context is, so you may want the rhythm snappy and a little tennis-match-esque to build tension, in which case none of this applies. 😛 But hopefully some part of it made sense and was helpful.












